What is the difference?
Excision removes a scar; elevation raises its base.
Excision usually leaves a small stitched closure. Elevation preserves the scar’s base and repositions it closer to the surrounding skin.

Acne scar treatment
Punch excision and punch elevation are small surgical techniques that remove or lift selected depressed acne scars to soften their appearance.
What is the difference?
Excision removes a scar; elevation raises its base.
Excision usually leaves a small stitched closure. Elevation preserves the scar’s base and repositions it closer to the surrounding skin.
Which scars can it treat?
Selected narrow, deep or sharply edged depressed scars.
Excision may suit deep ice-pick or small boxcar scars. Elevation is generally considered for selected boxcar scars with a usable base.
Will scars disappear?
No. The goal is improvement, not scar-free skin.
A deep depression may become a smaller surgical scar or a shallower indentation. Other treatments may still be needed.
01 · Overview
Punch techniques target individual depressions rather than treating every acne scar in an area. They are different from a punch biopsy, which removes tissue mainly for diagnosis. Scar revision aims to make a scar less noticeable, not erase it. [1]
During punch excision, the surgeon uses a small circular instrument to remove the scar and then closes the opening, usually with stitches. During punch elevation, the surgeon frees the scar’s base around its edges and lifts it toward the level of nearby skin. [2]
Many people have a mixture of ice-pick, boxcar, and rolling scars. A surgeon may recommend punch treatment for only some of them and a different approach for the rest. Active acne, skin tone, and your history of healing all affect the plan. [2]
Broad, shallow or tethered scars may not benefit from removing a small circle of skin. Treating many closely spaced scars also requires careful planning to avoid excessive tension and crowded closures.
No. Subcision releases bands beneath a depressed scar, often a rolling scar. Punch excision removes a scar, while punch elevation lifts a defined scar base.
02 · Concerns & Goals
A few deep scars can draw your attention even when the surrounding skin is fairly smooth. Treatment depends on each scar’s depth, shape, and location.
Some ice-pick scars extend too deeply for surface treatment alone. Excision may be considered when the scar’s size and location allow a suitable closure.
Selected boxcar scars may be candidates for elevation if the base can be lifted and positioned securely.
Punch treatment addresses specific spots. Nearby rolling scars, enlarged pores, or widespread texture changes may need a separate approach.
Red or brown acne marks without an indentation are not usually targets for punch surgery. Surgery can itself cause temporary or lasting color changes.
03 · Options
These are approaches to discuss, not interchangeable treatments. Your surgeon should explain which scars are suitable and what will replace each treated depression.

Removes a selected scar and closes the small opening.
Raises the base of a selected depressed scar.
Treats selected scars across more than one visit.
Combines focal scar surgery with a separate texture treatment.
Scar shape and healing history matter more than choosing a technique by name. Your surgeon may advise another treatment or no procedure. [1] [2].
No. Punch grafting fills an excised opening with a small piece of skin taken from another site. Elevation uses the existing scar base. Grafting adds a donor wound and can create color or contour mismatch.
Sometimes. Different scars may need different techniques, but spacing, skin tension, and the number of wounds help determine whether one visit or staged treatment makes more sense.
04 · Results
Improvement usually means a less conspicuous scar, not its removal without a trace.
Early redness and swelling can hide the final contour.
Untreated scars and skin texture remain.
Scar revision cannot guarantee a particular degree of improvement. Final appearance depends on the scar, technique, and your individual healing response. [1]
05 · Recovery
Returning to work does not mean fully healed. Follow your surgeon’s instructions; strenuous activity requires clearance.
Recovery depends on the number and location of wounds, the closure method, and any combined treatment. Your surgical team’s instructions take priority over general timelines.
Step 1 · Day of treatment
Local anesthetic commonly numbs the area. Small dressings may cover the wounds. Before leaving, confirm how to care for each site and when to return.
Step 2 · First several days
Mild soreness, redness, swelling, or a little spotting can occur. Follow the prescribed cleaning and dressing plan rather than your usual skin-care routine.
Step 3 · Often within the first 1–2 weeks
Your team checks healing and removes non-dissolving stitches when appropriate. Timing varies by site and closure; do not remove stitches yourself.
Step 4 · Following weeks to months
Redness and firmness usually change gradually. Discuss sun protection and when, if ever, another scar treatment should begin.
Ask your surgical team whether compresses are appropriate and exactly how to use them.

Your team should give you a product-by-product plan. Some topical products may need to be kept away from healing wounds. Oral medicines, including isotretinoin, need an individualized discussion rather than a universal stop date.
Swelling and early healing can change the contour. Contact your surgeon rather than pressing, picking, or trying to flatten the area. Decisions about revision usually require a healing assessment.
06 · Safety
Small treated areas may have tenderness, redness, swelling, crusting, or minor spotting early on. These should generally improve rather than steadily worsen.
Increasing redness, warmth, pain, or drainage needs prompt assessment and may require treatment.
Bleeding can occur during or after treatment. Persistent bleeding needs advice from your surgical team.
A closure can separate or heal slowly, potentially leaving a wider scar.
Surgical scars can widen, thicken, or form keloids, particularly in people with a history of raised scars.
Skin may become darker or lighter, and temporary or lasting altered sensation is possible.
An elevated base may sink or remain raised. A visible edge, persistent depression, or dissatisfaction may lead to discussion of further treatment.
Discuss these risks and your individual health history with your surgeon. [1]
07 · Costs
Compare written estimates for the same planned scope: which scars will be treated, which techniques will be used, and whether visits or additional treatments are separate.
Surgeon
Assessment, the planned punch procedures, and wound closure.
Ask your surgeonAsk whether the charge is based on the session, treatment area, or number of scars.
Facility
Local anesthesia and use of the treatment space, with other anesthesia services if planned.
Ask your surgeonAsk which charges are included and whether any are billed separately.
Supplies
Dressings, wound checks, and stitch removal when needed.
Ask your surgeonConfirm whether prescriptions, extra visits, or later revision are additional.
TRC
Any separately described scheduling or care-coordination services.
Ask TRCAsk whether a Patient Services charge applies and exactly what it includes.
Your written estimate should explain the services included, any separate charges, and payment terms.
08 · Questions
The numbing injection may briefly sting. You may feel pressure during treatment, but tell the surgeon if you feel pain. Soreness afterward varies with the treatment scope.
Usually not. Punch techniques target changes in skin depth and structure, not color alone. A clinician can help distinguish marks from depressed scars.
It may be, but darker or lighter marks can develop after surgery. Discuss your pigment history and the surgeon’s experience treating similar skin tones.
There is no fixed number. Some scars may be addressed in one session; others need staged treatment or another technique. Your surgeon should explain the initial plan without promising a final result.
0 consultation questions in your plan
View in My TRC workspaceMy Aesthetic Plan
Bring these to help your consultation:
Choices stay in this visit until saving to your account completes. Nothing is sent to a clinician.
Photographs are illustrative scenes, not patients, staff, facilities or outcomes. This information does not replace a personal assessment by your treating clinician.