Illustrative lifestyle photograph; not a surgical result.

Acne scar treatment

Punch Excision / Elevation (Acne Scars)

Punch excision and punch elevation are small surgical techniques that remove or lift selected depressed acne scars to soften their appearance.

What is the difference?

Excision removes a scar; elevation raises its base.

Excision usually leaves a small stitched closure. Elevation preserves the scar’s base and repositions it closer to the surrounding skin.

Which scars can it treat?

Selected narrow, deep or sharply edged depressed scars.

Excision may suit deep ice-pick or small boxcar scars. Elevation is generally considered for selected boxcar scars with a usable base.

Will scars disappear?

No. The goal is improvement, not scar-free skin.

A deep depression may become a smaller surgical scar or a shallower indentation. Other treatments may still be needed.

01 · Overview

A focused approach to individual acne scars

Punch techniques target individual depressions rather than treating every acne scar in an area. They are different from a punch biopsy, which removes tissue mainly for diagnosis. Scar revision aims to make a scar less noticeable, not erase it. [1]

During punch excision, the surgeon uses a small circular instrument to remove the scar and then closes the opening, usually with stitches. During punch elevation, the surgeon frees the scar’s base around its edges and lifts it toward the level of nearby skin. [2]

Many people have a mixture of ice-pick, boxcar, and rolling scars. A surgeon may recommend punch treatment for only some of them and a different approach for the rest. Active acne, skin tone, and your history of healing all affect the plan. [2]

Treatment area
Individual depressed acne scars
Typical setting
Office procedure, often with local anesthesia
Treatment scope
Selected scars rather than the whole skin surface
Healing outlook
Early wound healing followed by months of scar settling
Why not treat every scar with a punch?

Broad, shallow or tethered scars may not benefit from removing a small circle of skin. Treating many closely spaced scars also requires careful planning to avoid excessive tension and crowded closures.

Is this the same as subcision?

No. Subcision releases bands beneath a depressed scar, often a rolling scar. Punch excision removes a scar, while punch elevation lifts a defined scar base.

02 · Concerns & Goals

What you may want to address

A few deep scars can draw your attention even when the surrounding skin is fairly smooth. Treatment depends on each scar’s depth, shape, and location.

  • Deep, narrow pits

    Some ice-pick scars extend too deeply for surface treatment alone. Excision may be considered when the scar’s size and location allow a suitable closure.

  • Sharply edged depressions

    Selected boxcar scars may be candidates for elevation if the base can be lifted and positioned securely.

  • Uneven texture

    Punch treatment addresses specific spots. Nearby rolling scars, enlarged pores, or widespread texture changes may need a separate approach.

  • Visible marks or color changes

    Red or brown acne marks without an indentation are not usually targets for punch surgery. Surgery can itself cause temporary or lasting color changes.

My Aesthetic Plan

Select any that matter to you. These are discussion priorities, not a recommendation.

Tap a card to mark it as a priority.

03 · Options

How the approaches differ

These are approaches to discuss, not interchangeable treatments. Your surgeon should explain which scars are suitable and what will replace each treated depression.

Compare the approaches

Illustrative lifestyle scene—not patients or treatment results.

Punch excision with closure

Removes a selected scar and closes the small opening.

How it worksA circular cutting instrument removes the scar tissue; stitches usually bring the skin edges together.
May suitSelected deep ice-pick or small boxcar scars.
Main tradeoffReplaces the depression with a surgical scar that may widen, remain visible, or develop unevenness.

Punch elevation

Raises the base of a selected depressed scar.

How it worksThe surgeon releases the base around its sides, lifts it, and secures it near the surrounding skin level.
May suitSelected sharply defined boxcar scars with a base suitable for preservation.
Main tradeoffThe base may settle, heal too high or too low, or leave a visible circular edge.

Staged punch treatment

Treats selected scars across more than one visit.

How it worksThe surgeon groups or spaces treatments according to scar location, closure tension, and healing.
May suitPeople with several suitable scars or closely spaced areas requiring a cautious plan.
Main tradeoffRequires repeated visits and separate healing periods; later treatment depends on earlier healing.

Punch treatment with later blending

Combines focal scar surgery with a separate texture treatment.

How it worksAfter adequate healing, a surgeon may consider resurfacing or another treatment for surrounding texture.
May suitMixed acne scarring that cannot be addressed by punch treatment alone.
Main tradeoffAdds recovery, cost, and risks such as pigment changes; it is not necessary or suitable for everyone.

Scar shape and healing history matter more than choosing a technique by name. Your surgeon may advise another treatment or no procedure. [1] [2].

Is punch grafting the same as elevation?

No. Punch grafting fills an excised opening with a small piece of skin taken from another site. Elevation uses the existing scar base. Grafting adds a donor wound and can create color or contour mismatch.

Can excision and elevation be used at the same visit?

Sometimes. Different scars may need different techniques, but spacing, skin tension, and the number of wounds help determine whether one visit or staged treatment makes more sense.

04 · Results

What may improve and what may remain

A change in scar shape

Improvement usually means a less conspicuous scar, not its removal without a trace.

  • Excision trades a depression for a small closure scar.
  • Elevation aims to reduce depth, but an edge or indentation can remain.

A result that develops gradually

Early redness and swelling can hide the final contour.

  • The treated sites can look more noticeable at first.
  • Scar color, firmness, and shape can continue changing for months.

A focused rather than full-face change

Untreated scars and skin texture remain.

  • Further treatment may be considered after healing.
  • New acne can cause new scars even when treated sites heal well.

Scar revision cannot guarantee a particular degree of improvement. Final appearance depends on the scar, technique, and your individual healing response. [1]

05 · Recovery

Planning your recovery

Recovery at a glance

Stay after surgery
Determined by Your Surgeon
Initial recovery at home
Varies by Individual
Return to desk work
Varies by Procedure and Work Activity
Light daily activities
Based on Individual Recovery
Strenuous exercise
Based on Surgeon Clearance

Returning to work does not mean fully healed. Follow your surgeon’s instructions; strenuous activity requires clearance.

Recovery depends on the number and location of wounds, the closure method, and any combined treatment. Your surgical team’s instructions take priority over general timelines.

  1. Step 1 · Day of treatment

    Treatment day

    Local anesthetic commonly numbs the area. Small dressings may cover the wounds. Before leaving, confirm how to care for each site and when to return.

  2. Step 2 · First several days

    Early wound care

    Mild soreness, redness, swelling, or a little spotting can occur. Follow the prescribed cleaning and dressing plan rather than your usual skin-care routine.

  3. Step 3 · Often within the first 1–2 weeks

    Wound review

    Your team checks healing and removes non-dissolving stitches when appropriate. Timing varies by site and closure; do not remove stitches yourself.

  4. Step 4 · Following weeks to months

    Scar settling

    Redness and firmness usually change gradually. Discuss sun protection and when, if ever, another scar treatment should begin.

Planning everyday activities

ActivityGeneral planning contextWhat affects the plan
Work and social plansPlanning context: Some people feel ready for desk work soon after a small treatment, while others prefer time away.What affects it: Visible dressings, redness, wound location, and job demands matter. Returning to work does not mean healing is complete.
ExercisePlanning context: Ask when you can resume strenuous activity.What affects it: Sweat, friction, and skin tension may irritate wounds or disrupt a closure.
Makeup and skin carePlanning context: Wait for clearance before applying makeup or acne products over treated sites.What affects it: Open wounds and healing skin may react to exfoliants, retinoids, and fragranced products.
Outdoor timePlanning context: Ask how to protect the area during early healing and when sunscreen can be applied. [1]What affects it: Sun exposure can make scar discoloration more noticeable.

Ask your surgical team whether compresses are appropriate and exactly how to use them.

Before your procedure

  • Identify the individual scars that bother you most and discuss realistic changes.
  • Review active acne and whether it should be controlled before surgery.
  • Share any history of raised scars, pigment changes, cold sores, or slow healing.
  • List medicines, supplements, allergies, and current or past isotretinoin use; do not stop prescribed medicines on your own.
  • Discuss smoking, vaping, and nicotine use because they can affect healing.
  • Arrange follow-up, wound-care supplies, and time away from activities according to your treatment plan.

Prepare for your visit

Illustrative preparation scene—not postoperative care instructions.
Can I keep using acne medication?

Your team should give you a product-by-product plan. Some topical products may need to be kept away from healing wounds. Oral medicines, including isotretinoin, need an individualized discussion rather than a universal stop date.

What if an elevated scar looks uneven?

Swelling and early healing can change the contour. Contact your surgeon rather than pressing, picking, or trying to flatten the area. Decisions about revision usually require a healing assessment.

06 · Safety

Risks and what your clinician assesses

Small treated areas may have tenderness, redness, swelling, crusting, or minor spotting early on. These should generally improve rather than steadily worsen.

Infection

Increasing redness, warmth, pain, or drainage needs prompt assessment and may require treatment.

Bleeding or bruising

Bleeding can occur during or after treatment. Persistent bleeding needs advice from your surgical team.

Delayed healing or wound opening

A closure can separate or heal slowly, potentially leaving a wider scar.

New or raised scarring

Surgical scars can widen, thicken, or form keloids, particularly in people with a history of raised scars.

Pigment or sensation changes

Skin may become darker or lighter, and temporary or lasting altered sensation is possible.

Uneven contour or limited improvement

An elevated base may sink or remain raised. A visible edge, persistent depression, or dissatisfaction may lead to discussion of further treatment.

Discuss these risks and your individual health history with your surgeon. [1]

What your clinician assesses

  • Scar depth, width, edges, location, and available skin for closure.
  • Skin tone and history of dark marks, light marks, keloids, or thick scars.
  • Active acne, local infection, and previous scar treatments.
  • Health conditions, medicines, nicotine use, and expectations that may affect treatment or healing.

07 · Costs

What makes up the Total Procedure & Care Cost

Compare written estimates for the same planned scope: which scars will be treated, which techniques will be used, and whether visits or additional treatments are separate.

Surgeon

Surgical care

Assessment, the planned punch procedures, and wound closure.

Ask your surgeonAsk whether the charge is based on the session, treatment area, or number of scars.

Facility

Anesthesia and facility

Local anesthesia and use of the treatment space, with other anesthesia services if planned.

Ask your surgeonAsk which charges are included and whether any are billed separately.

Supplies

Supplies and follow-up

Dressings, wound checks, and stitch removal when needed.

Ask your surgeonConfirm whether prescriptions, extra visits, or later revision are additional.

TRC

Patient Services

Any separately described scheduling or care-coordination services.

Ask TRCAsk whether a Patient Services charge applies and exactly what it includes.

Your written estimate should explain the services included, any separate charges, and payment terms.

08 · Questions

Common questions

Does punch treatment hurt?

The numbing injection may briefly sting. You may feel pressure during treatment, but tell the surgeon if you feel pain. Soreness afterward varies with the treatment scope.

Can it treat flat red or brown acne marks?

Usually not. Punch techniques target changes in skin depth and structure, not color alone. A clinician can help distinguish marks from depressed scars.

Is treatment suitable for darker skin tones?

It may be, but darker or lighter marks can develop after surgery. Discuss your pigment history and the surgeon’s experience treating similar skin tones.

How many sessions will I need?

There is no fixed number. Some scars may be addressed in one session; others need staged treatment or another technique. Your surgeon should explain the initial plan without promising a final result.

My Consultation Questions

Select any to bring with you.

0 consultation questions in your plan

View in My TRC workspace

My Aesthetic Plan

Prepare for your consultation

Bring these to help your consultation:

  • Confirm the scars, technique, and goals in the treatment plan.
  • Get individualized wound-care instructions and a follow-up date.
  • Keep the written estimate and daytime and after-hours contact details.
View My Aesthetic Plan

Choices stay in this visit until saving to your account completes. Nothing is sent to a clinician.

Sources

  1. [1]American Society of Plastic Surgeons — Scar RevisionScar revision goals and limitations; consultation, surgical risks, healing, follow-up, sun protection, and symptoms requiring urgent attention.
  2. [2]Cleveland Clinic — Acne ScarsAcne scar types; punch excision and elevation; selection of treatments according to scar type; alternative scar treatments and prevention of new acne scarring.

Photographs are illustrative scenes, not patients, staff, facilities or outcomes. This information does not replace a personal assessment by your treating clinician.